Investigating the impact of sister-cities on urban development with emphasis on urban diplomacy and national development, Case Study: Shiraz metropolis

Document Type : Original Research

Author
S. afzali
Ph.D Student of Geography and Urban Planing, Department of Geography, Islamic Azad University, Larestan Branch
Abstract
Introduction

Diplomacy is interaction with societies for securing benefits, increasing influence and reducing vulnerability through the least cost and efforts to prevent hostilities and increase political and economic cooperation and exchange of knowledge, art and preparation of foreign relations. Management diplomacy is a non-violent method with the aim of achieving interests and values and improving the political and economic position of a country in the world. Through official and unofficial representatives, diplomacy helps the government collect, coordinate and secures the public interests of the country. After the Treaty of Westphalia in 1648 and the emergence of nation-based government, the principles of diplomacy were established, though their history goes back to before Westphalia. Since the traditional diplomacy is only concerned with affairs between governments, the management of relations between countries, and the search for national interests, it is unable to respond to the current complexities of the world. Because after the Cold War, power has spread on a wider level [5], and the national sovereignty and the monopoly of the governments are weakening. At the beginning of the 21st century, NGOs and multinational companies played an increasing role in diplomacy. On this same basis, public diplomacy is the establishment and review of interaction between new players in the international arena beside the governments.

Cities and urban institutions are international actors that have created the new concept of urban diplomacy. Relying on the increasing attention to the economy and economic activities and aligning with the process of globalization and with proper use of diplomacy, cities are trying to protect their interests against the challenges of the global economy and the expansion of the security field in the appropriate and specific area of relations, i.e., the global network of cities, to increase opportunities in the fields of Foreign capital attraction, technology transfer, export of services and expansion of foreign trade. In this way, cities want to find a superior position in the field of global decision-making. Therefore, to reduce and monitor conflicts along with peace, interaction and sustainable income for local and global citizens, urban diplomacy is a set of urban policy tools and processes, institutions and economic, political, social and cultural arrangements of urban management in the form of local governments.

Urbanization is directly tied to modernization, industrialization and the wisdom-based sociological process. Today in the world, cities are more important than any issue, and as a political-social unit, they are growing in terms of power in the age of globalization. Cities are the driving force behind the development and economic growth of countries and more income, better health, and a better life; all indications of the reasons for urbanization's growth.

research method

The method of this research is mixed in that, according to the qualitative and quantitative data, the analysis tools and methods are inevitably qualitative and quantitative as well. The present article tried to use different tools, such as document and library fields, interviews and websites. The research is theoretical-applied and descriptive-analytical according to its nature and method. In accordance with the library data, four main components of the research were identified, and corresponding to them, indicators that can act as effective factors of sisterhood relationships in urban development were extracted.

Research findings

Based on the library sources and data and the background of the research conducted in the first step on the establishment of sisterhood relations between metropolises and urban development, twenty-six important indicators were identified. In the second step, these twenty-six indicators were placed into four main components, including: 1) political and sustainable security; 2) economic development; 3) development of human resources; and 4) socio-cultural development. The political component, sustainable security and human resources development have six indicators each, and the economic development and socio-cultural development components have seven indicators each.

conclusions

In establishing sisterhood relations, urban diplomacy and its impact on the urban development of Shiraz metropolis, the results obtained from two categories of library and field sources show some effective factors. According to the amount of research, a variety of indicators were identified in this field, which are placed and analyzed in four basic components: 1) political and sustainable security; 2) economic development; 3) human resources development; and 4) socio-cultural development. The findings showed that, compared to the past, sister city ties have had a great impact on the development of Shiraz metropolis.

Expansion of the globalization process of metropolises in bilateral and multilateral arenas and in the political, economic, social and cultural fields has a significant impact on strengthening the growing international interactions, realizing foreign policy goals and securing the interests of governmental and non-governmental actors in the international arena. The communication of cities in the process of multilateral interactions of economy and global politics and bilateral political and economic cooperation emphasizes the role of local officials as vital elements in order to strengthen friendly relations, resolve international conflicts, improve inter-nation and inter-city relations, and make appropriate use of diplomacy to increase opportunities in the fields of attracting foreign capital, transferring new technologies, exporting services, expanding foreign trade, strengthening the tourism industry, getting access to global markets, and protecting human interests against global problems and challenges. Shiraz metropolis also seeks to develop diplomacy with a number of cities in other countries through the conclusion of sisterhood agreements and various memoranda of understanding. Despite the opportunities and necessities that Shiraz has for the presence and promotion of productivity in the field of urban diplomacy, due to numerous obstacles, it does not have a suitable position in the field of urban diplomacy. Considering the obstacles of foreign relations and sanctions at the international level, paying attention to Shiraz's active role in the field of urban diplomacy is a double necessity. In this regard, goal-setting and macro-policy, as well as institution-building, planning and capacity-building with the aim of Shiraz cooperation in the field of urban diplomacy and playing an active role on international scientific, professional and specialized forums, are accessible due to its high capacity. The urban management complex, i.e., councils and municipalities and other service organizations, can benefit from seeking participation and maximum Participation by using the tools of active urban diplomacy in international urban organizations and, through each other's successful experiences, actively participating in global and local governance.

Keywords

Subjects

1- Amiri, Hashem (2017). Geopolitic, Diplomady and Behavior of powers, Tehran: Kanimehr.
2- Mohammadian, Ali and Alireza Rezaie (2016). The Evolution of the Concept of Diplomacy in International Relations, Iranian Research Letter of International Politics, Vol 5, No 1.
3- Surmacz, beata. (2018). City diplomacy, Barometer regionalny, 16 NR 1. http://yadda.icm.edu.pl/yadda/element/bwmeta1.element.ekon-element-000171517196.
4- McGrew, Anthony. (2011). Globalization and Global Politics, in John Baylis, Steve Smith & Patricia Owens (Eds.). The Globalization of World Politics: An Introduction to International Relations. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
5- Economou, E, Marios L, Metaxas, T. (2011). EU and US security policy from the cold war era to the 21st century: the institutional evolution of cfsp and the factors that determine the American military supremacy, Available at: https://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/41003/ MPRA Paper No. 41003.
6- Naghibzadeh, Ahmad (2014). History of Diplomacy and International Relations, Tehran: Ghomes.
7- Davenport, David. 2002. The New Diplomacy. Policy Review. No 116, December 2002/ January 2003. At https://www.researchgate.net/publication/324932685_New_Diplomacy.
8- Langhorne, Richard. 2005. The Diplomacy of Non- State Actors. Diplomacy and Statecraft, Vol 16, No 2, pp 331- 339.
9- Muldoon. Jr, James. 2005. The Diplomacy of Bisiness. Diplomasy and Statecraft, Vol. 16, No. 2, pp 341- 361.
10- Mosavi Khorshidi, Seyed Mohammad Javad (2015). The role of modern public diplomacy in securing the national interests of the Islamic Republic of Iran, Journal of Politic, Vol. 2, No.6, ]In Persian[.
11- Dehshiri, Mohammadreza and Mostafa Khorrami (2018). The Analyzing to Status of City Diplomacy in the Islamic Republic of Iran's Foreign Policy Journal of Foreign Policy, Volume:32 Issue: 1, ]In Persian[.
12- Mosavi Shafahi, Masood (2007). City diplomacy, Journal of Daneshe shahr, NO 18. ]In Persian[.
13- Daroudi, M.R and N. Peimani. 2013. Assessing Urban Diplomacy Approach on Foreign Investors in Tehran Using Network Analysis Process- SWOT Analysis, Middle East Journal of Scientific Research 15 (5): pp 715- 722.
14- Acuto, Michele, Mika Morissette. 2017. City Diplomacy: Towards More Strategic, Networking? Learning with WHO Healthy Cities, Global Policy Volume 8. Issu. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/1758-5899.12382.
15- Zarghani, S.H., M.J. Ranjkesh, M. Eskandaran (2014). City Diplomacy, analysis of the Role of Cities as the New Actor in International Relations, Journal Urban - Regional Studies and Research, Volume:5 Issue: 20. ]In Persian[.
16- Bush, Kenneth. 2003. Building Capacity for Peace and Unity: The Role of Local Government in Peace-building. Ontario: Fedration of Canadian Municipalities.
17- De Villiers, J. 2009. Success factors and the city-tocity partnership management process–from strategy to alliance capability. Habitat International, 33(2).
18- Afsane Khosravi and Others (2019). Necessity and Aequirements of Synergy Urban diplomacy with Public diplomacy in Cultural and Economic Interaction in Foreign policy, Journal of Political sociology of Islamic world, Volume:7 Issue: 15, ]In Persian[.
19- Mandiyambira, R. 2014. Navigating the Tides towards the Attainment of Sustainable Development. The Case of Masvingo Municipality, Zimbabwe. European Journal of Business and Management, 6 (1).
20- Buis, H. 2009. The role of local government associations in increasing the effectiveness of cityto-city cooperation. Habitat International, 33 (2), 190- 194.
21- Bontenbal, M., & Mamoon, D. 2017. Understanding City to City Cooperation: North South Partnerships of Local Authorities as Development Schemes. Munich Personal RePEc Archive. https://pdfs. semanticscholar.org/3863/5f8f5e01f8b0ab7140c227f02ae84db713c8.pdf.
22- Yamin, Muhammad and Arum Tri Utami. 2016. Towards Sister City Cooperation betweenCilacap and Mueang Chonburi District, Innovation in Regional Public Service for Sustainability (ICPM 2016), https://www.atlantis-press.com/proceedings/icpm-16/25857468
23- O’Toole, K. 2000. From Mates to Markets: Australian Sister City Type Relationships, Policy, Organisation and Society, 19:1, 43-64, DOI: 10.1080/10349952.2000.11876718, https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/10349952.2000.11876718.
24- Marchetti, Raffaele. 2017. City Diplomacy, How do you analyze the present status of city diplomacy? No 18 Academic Foresights. https://www.press.umich.edu/11991803/city_diplomacy.
25- Shaw, S., & Karlis, G. 2002. Sister-city partnerships and cultural recreation: The case of Scarborough, Canada and Sagamihara, Japan. World Leisure Journal, 44(4), 44-50.
26- McLarty, Dustin. Nora Davis, Joshua Gellers, Nasrin Nasrollahi & Erik Altenbernd. 2014. Sisters in sustainability: municipal partnerships for social, environmental, and economic growth. Sustainability Science V 9, https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11625-014-0248-6.
27- Gries, Thomas and Rainer Grundmann. 2015. Fertility and Modernization: The Role of Urbanization in Developing Countries, Journal of International Development, Volume30, Issue3, Pages 493-506, https://doi.org/10.1002/jid.3104.
28- Savir, Uri. 2003. Glocalization: A New Balance of Power, Development Outreach. Special Report: Unknown cities. November 2003.
29- Farhangdost, Mohammad (2018). Investigating the Relationship between Urbanization and Economic Growth in Iran, New Applied Studies in Management, No 4, Issue 1. ]In Persian[.
30- Mirabadi, Mostafa, Sadegh Besharatifar, Ahmad Karimi (2018). An Analysis on the spatial pattern, dimensions and related factors to urbanism growth of contemporary in Iran (Emphasizing on development and livelihood indexes), Geographical Urban Planning Research, Volume:6 Issue: 3, ] In Persian[.
31- Kavandikateb, Abolfazl, Mohammadreza Hafeznia (2021). Expounding the Relation between Rapid Urbanization and Economic Ideology of the State in Political Management of National Space, Journal of Spatial Planning, Volume:24 Issue: 4, ] In Persian[.
32- Bakhtiyari, S. and Others (2011). Assessing the development status of the cities of Yazd province, Quarterly Journal of Planning and Budgeting, No 3, ] In Persian[.
33- Shafiei, Zahed and Others (2016). Sustainable tourism from theory to practice: A critical perspective, Journal of Geography, Volume:14 Issue: 49,] In Persian[.
34- Hediger, W. (2000). Sustainable development and social welfare, Ecological Economics, 32, pp 481-492.
35- Navabakhsh, Mehrdad and Mohammad Bazafshan (2014). Assessing the extent of sustainable urban development in Shiraz in the last 10 years, Iranian Social Development Studies, Volume:3 Issue: 6, ] In Persian[.
36- Nesari, Reza and Others (2015). Sustainable Financing Strategies of Tehran Municipality in the Five-Year Plan, Emphasizing Issued Resistive Economy Policies, Journal of Urban Economics and Management, Volume:3 Issue: 11, In Persian[.
37- Hajilou, Mehran and Others (2017). Studying Sustainable Revenue Sources of Municipalities (Case: Shabestar, East Azerbaijan Province), Journal of Urban Economics and Management, Volume:5 Issue: 20, ] In Persian[.
38- Goodarzi, Mahnaz and Others (2017). City's measurement ratio & diplomacy in globalization era, Journal Strategic Studies of Public Policy, Volume:7 Issue: 23, ] In Persian[.
39- Azar, Adel and Others (2016). Research in soft operations, Tehran: Industrial Management Intitute, ] In Persian[.
40- Baycan. Tuzin. Seda Kundak and Aliye Ahu Gulumser Akgun (2006). Eurocities and Their "Sisters": How Are They Close to Each Other? 46th European Congress of the European Regional Science Association Enlargement, Southern Europe and the Mediterranean August 30th – September 3rd, 2006 Volos, Greece. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/23732251_Eurocities_and_Their_Sisters_How_Are_They_Close_to_Each_Other.
41- Hewitt, Ted. 1999. Cities Working to Improve Urban Services in Developing Areas: The Toronto- Sao Paulo Examples, Studies in Comparative International Development, Vol. 34, No 1. Pp 27- 44.
42- Statistical yearbook of Shiraz (2019). Shiraz: shiraz municipality, ] In Persian[.
43- Ehsanifarid, Mina (2012). Explain the role of sister cities in increasing convergence and developing political and cultural relations with Shiraz, Isfahan, University Of Isfahan, ] In Persian[.
44- Pacione, Michael. 2009. Urban Geography, A Global Perspective, London and New York: Routledge.
45- O’Toole, K. 2001. Kokusaika and Internationalisation: Australian and Japanese Sister City Type Relationships. Australian Journal of International Affairs, Vol. 55, No. 3, pp. 403–419. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/232823455_Kokusaika_and_Internationalisation_Australian_and_Japanese_Sister_City_Type_Relationships.
46- Konuk, Nukhet, N. Gamze Turan and Yuksel Ardali (2016), The Importance of Urbanization in Education, The Eurasia Proceedings of Educational & Social Sciences (EPESS), Volume 5, Pages 232-236.
47- Saunier, Pierre-Yves and Shane Ewen. 2008. Another Global City, Historical Explorations into the Transnational Municipal Moment, 1850–2000. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
48- Soleymani AliReza, Asghar Nazariyan (2012). A Study on Centralization and Decentralization of the Globalization factors in the Megalopolises of Developing countries (Case study of Tehran), Geography and Territorial Spatial Arrangement, Volume:2 Issue: 3, ] In Persian[.
49- Omrani, M. and Others (2014). Urban diplomacy and its role in urban branding, Mashhad: 6th National Conference on Urban Planing and Management with Emphasis on the Elements of Islamic City, ] In Persian[.
50- Basirat, Meysam, Seyyed Mostafa Jalili (2014). Analysis of opportunities and challenges of development of city diplomacy in Tehran metropolis, HOnar - ha - ye - ziba Memari - va - shahrsazi, Volume:19 Issue: 3, ] In Persian[.
51- Hatamiezhad, Hussein and ali mehdi (2010). Investigating sister-city relation to the concepts of globalization, Journal Of Shahrdariha, Volume 100, Isusue 11, ] In Persian[.
52- Hakimi, Seyed Abdollah, Majid Nasiri (2021). The role of sister city in creating sustainable income of municipalities using ism approach, Motaleate Shahri, Volume:10 Issue: 39, ] In Persian[.
53- Ghorchi, Morteza, Javad Kavianirad (2019). A Study of the Consistency of Urban Diplomacy with Foreign Policy of the Islamic Republic of Iran; Case Study: Sister Cities of Tehran, Geopolitics, Volume:15 Issue: 1, ] In Persian[.
54- Zahrani, Mostafa, Alireza Rajaei (2020). Opportunities for international cooperation with the sister cities approach, Journal of Political Interpretation Knowledge, Volume:2 Issue: 3, ] In Persian[.
55- McDonnell, M.J. and Pickett, S.T.A. 1990. Ecosystem structure and function along urban- rural gradients: An unexploited opportunity for ecology. Ecology 71, Pages 1232–1236.
56- Ragier van der Pluijm Jan Melissen. 2007. City Diplomacy: The Expanding Role of Cities in International Politics. The Netherlands Institute of International Relations. https://www.uclg.org/sites/default/files/20070400_cdsp_paper_pluijm.pdf.
57- Chung, Mona and Mascitelli, Bruno. 2009. A new dimension of sister city relationships in the 21st century: a pilot study in Australia. Global Busines and Technology Association International Conference (11th: 2009: Prague, Czech Republic). https://dro.deakin.edu.au/eserv/DU:30026190/chung-anewdimension-2009-1.pdf.
58- Ogawa, Asuka. 2012. Sister City as Preservation Strategy. Degree of M.S., Columbia University, Thesis Advisors Jerome, Pamela S. https://academiccommons.columbia.edu/doi/10.7916/D85B08MD.
59- Gil. Cohen. 2020. The sister cities program and tourism. Journal of Hospitality and Tourism Management. Volume 45, December 2020, Pages 182-191. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1447677020301996.
60- Schraven. Daan. Simon Joss and Martin de Jong. 2021. Past, present, future: engagement with sustainable urban development through 35 city labels in the scientific literature 1990-2019. Journal of Cleaner Production. Volume 292, 10 April 2021, 125924. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S095965262100144X.
61- Liu, Xingjian and Xiaohui Hu. 2018. Are ‘Sister Cities’ from ‘Sister Provinces’? An Exploratory Study of Sister City Relations (SCRs) in China. Networks and Spatial Economics volume 18, pages 473– 491. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s11067-018-9408-z.
62- Henry Buckley, Patrick, Akio Takahashi and Amy Anderson. 2015. The Role of Sister Cities’ Staff Exchanges in Developing “Learning Cities”: Exploring Necessary and Sufficient Conditions in Social Capital Development Utilizing Proportional Odds Modeling, Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2015 Jul; 12 (7): 7133–7153. Published online 2015 Jun 24. Doi: 10.3390/ijerph120707133. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4515646/.
63- https://international.pte.hu/university/city-pecs.
Political Organizing of Space
Volume 5, Issue 4 - Serial Number 20
December 2023
Pages 436-453